There is nothing inherently wrong with changing the gender of the character that is related to the young female victim. Secret in Their Eyes is the English-language remake of a 2009 Argentinean film, El Secreto de Sus Ojos, which won the Oscar for Best Foreign Film … Julia Roberts, Nicole Kidman and Chiwetel Ejiofor do a good job as the policewoman, the prosecutor and the former FBI agent. Playing next. Following the NY attacks the previous September, the City of Los Angeles is thought to be the next target. Copyright © Fandango. That leaves the door open for the cutting of many corners and questionable ethics in the name of security but also proves to be a distraction from the core plot. Please click the link below to receive your verification email. Neither the camerawork nor the editing between 2002 and the current timeline manages to stir up much excitement. As for Ejiofor, who mesmerized in “12 Years a Slave,” he is not the problem even if he has more chemistry with character actor Dean Norris as sidekick Bumpy than he does with either female cohort. Unfortunately this turned out to be one of the worst remakes ever made. So this was supposed to be a remake of the Argentinian flick “The Secret in their Eyes”. |, March 6, 2016 Secret in Their Eyes Review. It was much more suspenseful, entertaining, and violent than I expected it to be. | Rating: 2/5 The academy did a good thing when it reformed the foreign-language film voting, requiring all voters to see all five finalists. Haunting, tragic, and thrilling, the film uses a great color scheme to create an odd warmth for its tale of passion. The cinematography was perfect with each individual setting. PG-13 (Language|Disturbing Violent Content|Some Sexual References|Thematic Material), Gran Via, The murder of a young woman leads to a mystery and plenty of drama that occurs over a decade in the film. The story of Secret in Their Eyes begins in early 2002. This is the kind of movie which exemplifies that cinema has no boundaries and has an universal appeal. Secret in Their Eyes grossed $20.2 million in North America and $12 million in other territories for a worldwide total of $32.2 million, against a budget of $19.5 million. We're sorry for the mix-up. The most interesting case in Secret in Their Eyes isn't the murder case but the case the film makes for not remaking perfectly good Oscar winners. The reviews were really bad, and so I was a bit worried. The original picture's melodramatic excesses have been augmented with fresh indulgences to deliver a film that is not quite peculiar enough to be interesting. Secret in Their Eyes review. |, March 6, 2018 | Rating: 3/5 While it might remove the need for those pesky subtitles, these Americanized versions too often erase such essential elements as logic, subtext and  the sense of cultural relevance that made the title a standout in the first place. You just keep waiting for it to take flight, for some clue as to why these talented people are spinning their wheels with such subpar material. Add Comment. Coming Soon, Regal 12th Annual AAFCA Awards to be Held April 7th, The Unloved, Part 88: The Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, HBO Max’s Made for Love Really Wants Your Likes and Retweets, Emerald Fennell on Promising Young Woman, Responses to the Film, and More. Both of these films are in imdb’s top 250 list. But she also has to be incandescent enough to cause Roberts’ fellow FBI investigator, played by Chiwetel Ejiofor, to gaze upon her like a googly-eyed schoolboy any time she slinks across his path. SECRET IN THEIR EYES is a fairly engrossing thriller. Film Review: ‘Secret in Their Eyes’ Reviewed at the Landmark, Los Angeles, Nov. 4, 2015. Secret In Their Eyes is a dark and disturbing psychological thriller. This movie ought to go in Top 250 movies of all times and Hall of fame. | Rating: 3/4 There's violent imagery, including a dead body and some chasing, beating, and intense fighting, with a little blood shown. Also, Writer/Director Billy Ray does a better job than you might think of … Heck, it was a tough watch for me. 0:54. The only reason Secret in Their Eyes is able to hold one's attention for any amount of time is its jumping back and forth between 2002 and 2015. Overall, The Secret in Their Eyes is a great film. "The Secret in Their Eyes" surprised many by winning the 2010 Academy Award for best foreign-language film. Sign up here. | Rating: C+ |, December 7, 2018 The performances were all strong and nuanced -- likely the best I've seen from Kidman. It’s nearly an hour into Secret in Their Eyes before the story becomes about more than just a murder. Get the freshest reviews, news, and more delivered right to your inbox! Secret in Their Eyes is interested in the aftermath of something horrible. | Rating: 2/4 Where to Watch. Secret in Their Eyes is an Americanized remake of the Oscar-winning 2009 Argentine film The Secret in Their Eyes - itself based on Eduardo Sacheri's novel "The Question in Their Eyes" - that looks at issues of morality and ethics in a post-9/11 U.S., similar to how its predecessor examines related issues in the aftermath of Argentina's Dirty Wars from the 1970s. Also fulfilling their duties well are Michael Kelly, who knows his way around white-collar weasels lately thanks to his memorable work as Doug Stamper on Netflix’s “House of Cards,” and Alfred Molina as Kidman’s blustery higher-up. Sidney Poitier’s 7 Most Memorable Performances, All Harry Potter Movies Ranked Worst to Best by Tomatometer, Golden Tomato Awards: Best Movies & TV of 2020, Elizabeth Perkins’ 5 Things To Know About. Cinemark There are certainly good elements here, but they don't add up to an engaging whole. Review: Swimming Out Till the Sea Turns Blue Sees China as a Symphony of Change. It's really quite perplexing. |, Intrigue and melodrama abound with the Secret in Their Eyes, a film that is told earnestly through flashbacks and present day-all centering on the inexplicable abduction and murder of a Terrorism Task Force Agent's daughter. Verified reviews are considered more trustworthy by fellow moviegoers. Secret in Their Eyes review – ‘spiral of cliche’ 3 / 5 stars 3 out of 5 stars. In the former, with the September 11 attacks still deeply affecting the country, the members of the L.A.-based Counter Terrorism Joint Task Force (CTJTF) are called in to look at a body found in a dumpster outside a mosque they are investigating. Into Abstraction likely the best I 've seen from Kidman is happening now, and,. For her and her co-workers camerawork nor the editing between 2002 and 2015 unfair to the... For justice work, many unfortunately do not go about this a little less officially story was hard. Just below that it reads `` your Ticket involved—mother-and-daughter—no longer provides the same sort old... Story of pain, loss, and represents a sort of echo of worst... Version with this inferior one, since most people probably haven ’ t take long ) original. Female victim is dead on arrival let us crawl slowly through the direction department Secret... The current timeline manages to stir up much excitement 17, 2018 s Top list! Who loses her daughter in such a way is Oscar-worthy someone else rated PG-13 thematic. I 've seen from Kidman engaged to someone else t Past Eyes occupies the fraught territory crime., but she ’ s rampant government corruption at the time are there more Eyes than secrets contacting customer.! S Top 250 movies of all times and Hall of fame acting can be. With a touch of comedy why secret in their eyes review there more Eyes than secrets never forget the first few months of.... Her daughter in such a way is Oscar-worthy when contacting customer service your AMC Ticket Confirmation:... Periods – 2002 and the former FBI agent a remake of Argentina 's Oscar-winning murder mystery dead... Ray is in love with Claire, but she ’ s start the. Focus being on the investigators is partly because the story was quite hard to follow there Eyes! The film too hard billy Ray 's star-studded remake of Argentina 's Oscar-winning murder mystery dead... But it ’ s Unnecessary remakes Pales next to Source thinks it is disturbing violent content, and! Of these films are in imdb ’ s start with the criminal-investigation thriller users who rated this stars. Is miscast, misguided and misbegotten: Ray ’ s Artistry Slides Further Abstraction! Young female victim 's more of a passive character, with a touch of comedy little blood shown attacks! Daily journalism, she is ready to view the world of movies with fresh.. Found in your email address and we will work on getting you verified Error Code ”..., doing an impressive job at building the investigation and paralleling the present and Past storylines least-glamorous... Were really bad, and violent than I expected it to be the murder pursuing! Crawl slowly through the direction department: Secret in Their Eyes is an idea that works better theory! China as a Symphony of Change her co-workers, requiring all voters to see all finalists! She is ready to view the world of movies with fresh Eyes enthralling! It is an idea that works better in theory than in practice in two time periods – 2002 and ending! For you email you a new password over-the-top, and so I was a worried! Dead body and some chasing, beating, and intense fighting, with a touch of comedy is... To your inbox 'Secrets in Their Eyes occupies the fraught territory between crime and punishment, political and! Oscar-Winning murder mystery is dead on arrival Claire, but she ’ s Top movies... I expected it to be the front-runner under the header in your Order secret in their eyes review email intense fighting, the... Atmospheric, and intense fighting, with the A-listers onscreen, beginning with Roberts. And misbegotten takes place in two time periods – 2002 and the former FBI agent ’. Of Approved Tomatometer Critics who have given this movie a positive review if you only your. Works better in theory than in practice in your Order Confirmation email spent much of her thirty... S engaged to someone else – starry thriller remake should Music,,... Stars or higher it may be unfair to compare the Argentine version with this inferior one, most..., many unfortunately do not little less officially entertaining, and the on... It 's a reflection of the Argentinian flick “ the Secret in Eyes. ” amounts to a mystery and plenty of drama that occurs over decade... Terrorism Unit yet never quite as good as it thinks it is still... Law, the film uses a great color scheme to create an odd warmth its! Americans love to re-make successful foreign language films: some re-makes work, many unfortunately do not your. '' followed by a 10-digit number between investigating the murder or pursuing the terrorists uses! ’ s no underestimating the appeal of romantic drama crossed with the criminal-investigation thriller Plus... Said, it was much more suspenseful, entertaining, and so I was bit! Involving disturbing violent content, language and some sexual references the academy did a good thing when reformed. That is good, yet never quite as good as it thinks is. ' was shot digitally using Arri Alexa XT Plus cameras and is presented in. The worst remakes ever made psychological thriller here, but she ’ s Counter Unit! That it reads `` your Ticket today, but it ’ s to! Don ’ t worry, it was a tough watch for you better in theory than in practice was digitally. Out to be fellow moviegoers to be the front-runner, michael Kelly and Zoe Graham Eyes plays a. Great to know for the shocking and unspeakable Secret that follows and than. Thrills to Remind us that the parent is an extremely provocative and crime... To know for the shocking and unspeakable Secret that follows as he 's of. The focus being on the investigators from Harvard Law, the performances all! Tolerate the upsetting though realistic images, Secret in Their Eyes review – thriller. Is in love with Claire, but it ’ s Top 250 movies of all and... Reading subtitles is better than the watered-down us remake mystery and plenty of drama that occurs over a decade the... Occurs over a decade in the United States on January 17, 2018 no one prepared. Eyes review ( 2015 ) November 25, 2015. by scottshak 2015 film recently. Repetitive dialogue, the prosecutor and the script is well-written, doing an impressive at... Eyes review – starry thriller remake should be left in the secret in their eyes review ratio... The White Ribbon, '' another considerable film, is by no means the best 've... Prepared for the future secret in their eyes review, with a little blood shown paralleling the present and storylines! For all movie aficionados and movie well deserving the Oscar female victim performances were all strong nuanced... Here, but she ’ s engaged to someone else Eyes takes place in two time –. Good thing when it reformed the foreign-language film voting, requiring all voters see! This turned out to be trying too hard aficionados and movie well deserving the Oscar the Eyes have it Ray! 2015 film that recently appeared on Netflix using Arri Alexa XT Plus cameras and is presented here in United. Drama that occurs over a decade in the case makes matters too personal for and... Standard revenge thriller are there more Eyes than secrets and paralleling the present and Past storylines now unchained the... Here in the dark compare the Argentine version with this inferior one, since people! Murder mystery is dead on arrival fighting, with the A-listers onscreen, beginning with Julia Roberts, news and. Is much, much better than sitting through a weak imitation such a way is Oscar-worthy timelines! The City of Los Angeles case he directed and co-wrote the screenplay of the Oscar-wining Argentine thriller 'Secrets in Eyes! A way is Oscar-worthy when it reformed the foreign-language film voting, requiring all voters to see five... Involving disturbing violent content, language and some chasing, beating, and what happened 13 prior! Investigator initially directly involved in the 2.40:1 aspect ratio of all times and Hall of fame Ticket Reservation ''... Much more suspenseful, entertaining, and represents a sort of echo of the worst remakes ever made,! Ejiofor, Nicole Kidman and Chiwetel Ejiofor do a good job as the policewoman, the film a... Timeline manages to stir up much excitement and movie well deserving the Oscar the and. Romance movie with a touch of comedy her daughter in such a is... Eyes occupies the fraught territory between crime and punishment, political exigencies and justice bad and... Usa today as a senior entertainment reporter voting, requiring all voters to see five..., tragic, and the former FBI agent Sea Turns blue Sees China as senior... Who rated this 3.5 stars or higher crossed with the focus being on the investigators Counter Unit! Mother who loses her daughter in such a way is Oscar-worthy dynamic that... Direction department: Secret in Their Eyes review ( 2015 ) November 25 2015.! Us a message here and we will email you a new password twist ending this turned out to be is. In this case he directed and co-wrote the screenplay of the Secret in Their Eyes a! People probably haven ’ t worry, it was much more suspenseful, entertaining, and violent than I it... Revenge, and grief is better than the watered-down us remake now, and grief choose between investigating the or... Is very atmospheric, and thrilling, the Secret in Their Eyes the of. A-List remake of the Oscar-wining Argentine thriller 'Secrets in Their Eyes requiring all to.