Compiled by Canadian and US lawyers and advocates. It also sends a crucial message, across Canada and beyond, that human rights violations will not be tolerated in Canada's national security operations; and there will be consequences and amends when violations occur. In 2017, the Liberal government of Prime Minister ​Justin Trudeau settled the Kha… Reservation Request, Stay Khadr (“ Khadr 2008 ”), this Court held that the regime in place at Guantanamo Bay constituted a clear violation of Canada’s international human rights obligations, and, under s. 7 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, ordered the Canadian government to disclose to K the transcripts of the interviews he had given to CSIS and DFAIT, which it did. Reports, Year in Calculate Deadlines for Serving and Filing Documents, Filing in SCC Judgments, Court Game, About the On 10 July 2008, the Prime Minister of Canada announced that he would not seek Mr. Khadr’s repatriation. On July 22, 2010, the Federal Court of Appeal granted a stay pending appeal of the most recent order of the Federal Court after hearing the appeal by teleconference on July 16, 2010. Brief, Judgments List of all Chief Justices and Judges, Webcasts of Role of the Court, News Facilities, Media Briefings and Lock-ups, Access to Court Today's settlement is acknowledgment that Canadian action and inaction contributed substantially to the human rights violations experienced by a young man whose ordeal began when he was captured as a 15 year-old child soldier. AU.027. Catalogue, Accessibility appeal to the Supreme Court of 44, the Supreme Court of Canada found that Khadr had a right to a remedy under s. 24(2) for the violation of his Charter rights by the Canadian government. Request, Resources for 2017, Winnipeg Seating Policy and Procedure, The Day of the Omar Khadr’s appeal in the United States is considered to have a very strong chance of success based on rulings in similar cases. Omar Khadr is a 17 year-old Canadian citizen who has been detained since 2002 by the US government as a result of his alleged involvement with Al-Qaeda forces in Afghanistan. Loan Procedures, Library Questions, Guided Omar Khadr case, the imprisonment, trial, and eventual release of Omar Khadr, a Toronto -born Canadian, captured by U.S. soldiers after a firefight in Afghanistan in 2002 when he was 15 years old. Beginnings of the Court, General He spent his childhood moving back and forth between Canada and Pakistan. Mr. Khadr was 15 years old at the time. Amnesty International applied to intervene in Mr. Khadr’s case before the Federal Court of Appeal and Supreme Court of Canada. Omar Kh… Summary Omar Khadr, a Canadian citizen, was 15 years old when he was captured and seriously injured in a firefight in Afghanistan on 27 July 2002. While the government did not challenge any of that evidence, Public Safety Minister Blaney announced immediately after the bail ruling that the government would appeal the decision. The Federal Court of Appeal upheld the Federal Court’s Judgment. Temp. 23A (Combined 23A and 23B Dynamic PDF), Form Canada’s response was a diplomatic note asking the United States not to use information turned over by Canadian agents. The Supreme Court in Canada v. Khadr 2008 SCC 28 was faced with a fascinating situation which afforded the Court an opportunity to assess the relationship between a citizen and his government on the one hand and the relationship between the government and her foreign sovereigns. The judgment of Khadr v. Canada provides a recent case study of how the highest court in Canada has dealt with the matter so far. Canada ordered disclosure on the basis that the United States Supreme Court had found the Guantanamo military commission process in place when the Canadian officials interviewed Khadr to be illegal: Canada (Justice) v Khadr, 2008 SCC 28, [2008] 2 SCR 125 [Khadr I]. On a motion to produce such undertakings, this Court ruled in Khadr v. Canada 2005 FC 632 at para 20: Since he is being held in a US prison, but the role of Canadian security officers is not clear, the issue of liability under the Charter needs to be litigated. A Canadian captured by American forces in Afghanistan at the age of 15, Omar Khadr is currently on interim release from prison in Canada pending an appeal of his war-crimes conviction before a military commission in Guantanamo Bay. the Hearing, Reserved The Khadr family had moved to Peshawar, Pakistan, in 1985, where his father worked for charities helping Afghan refugees.. JL.037. In Canada (Prime Minister) v. Khadr, [2010] 1 S.C.R. University of Ottawa Foreign Policy Practicum, "Repatriation of Omar Khadr to Be Tried Under Canadian Law" (Brief Submitted to Canadian Senate Standing Committee on Human Rights), January 2008 (PDF) 7. of the Court (PDF), Poster In July 2010, Canada’s Federal Court in Khadr v. Canada gave the government seven days to supply a list of all possible remedies to cure the continuing Charter violations. 23A (PDF for print), Form The government initially chose to defend itself against the suit. The Federal Court of Canada found that Canada had violated Mr. Khadr’s section 7 rights and ordered that he be repatriated. of Legal Information Available to the General information about seeking leave to Our motion was denied by the Federal Court of Appeal but leave to intervene was granted before the Supreme Court of Canada. Canadian charter - civil. connected. Omar Khadr, a 26-year-old Canadian, had been in the U.S. detention camp in Cuba's Guantanamo Bay since 2002. This article examines the appropriateness of declaratory orders in cases involving continuing human rights violations through the recent Canadian Supreme Court decision of Khadr v Canada (Prime Minister). Mr. Khadr challenged this decision and requested that he be recognized as a youth offender and transferred into a provincial institution. for Judgments, Judgments In 2014, a Federal Courtjudge allowed him to amend the $10-million civil suit he had launched in 2004. List of detainees transferred out of GTMO(PDF) 4. In 2005, Mr. Khadr was declared an enemy combatant and the US laid formal charges against him. Library, Policies and Conditions, More about the The compensation and apology come after the Supreme Court of Canada ruled in 2010 that Canadian intelligence officials obtained evidence from Khadr under “oppressive circumstances,” such as sleep deprivation, during interrogations at Guantanamo Bay in 2003. v. Omar Ahmed Khadr (Federal Court) (Civil) (By Leave) Keywords. He had found himself in a fire fight and allegedly threw a grenade which resulted in the death of a US soldier. Any such decision must be reviewable in Canadian courts. Tour, Educational Former Judges, Alphabetical and Other Limitations on Access, Statistics 62; 613 W.A.C. Review, Frequently Asked application for leave to appeal, Important Mr. Khadr applied to the Federal Court to judicially review the Prime Minister’s decision, arguing that it violated his rights under section 7 of the Charter. “Canada has a history of recognizing and apologizing when it … In Canada v. Khadr, 2008 SCC 28, the SCC addressed the applicability of the Charter to the actions of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) and other Canadian officials when they interrogated Omar Khadr at Guantánamo Bay in 2003 and passed on the results of these interrogations to American military officials. attachments), How to Saudi Arabia: Release women human rights defenders now! “The rule of law was violated,” Meighen told Global News, explaining that Khadr wasn’t given a fair trial. At the time of his transfer, Mr. Khadr was 26 years old and had been imprisoned for 10 years. The treatment of Khadr was also inconsistent with Canadian principles regarding the treatment of juveniles in the criminal context. leave to appeal, Glossary JUSTICE von FINCKENSTEIN BETWEEN: OMAR AHMED KHADR by his Next Friend FATMAH EL-SAMNAH Plaintiff and THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF CANADA and THE MINISTER OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS Defendants REASONS FOR ORDER AND ORDER [1] Omar Khadr is a 17 year-old Canadian citizen who has been detained since 2002 by the US government as a result of his alleged involvement with Al-Qaeda … for Judgments, Cases in Trial, Youth At minimum, these rules require that the detained citizen be afforded the right to be heard and to receive adequate reasons when a decision is made on the repatriation request. Omar Khadr as Child Soldier(PDF) 3. a Speaker from the Court, Guided Tour However, the Supreme Court left determination of the appropriate remedy … Cite: [2009] N.R. When these interrogations occurred, Canadian officials were aware that Mr. Khadr had been subject to sleep deprivation techniques by the US authorities. To read more about our intervention, click here. for the, All to the 2019 Amendments to the, Fees Court, Office of the Registrar Positions, Terms in Leave Applications, Bulletins In a rare decision made from the bench immediately after the hearing on 14 May 2015, the Supreme Court of Canada formally recognized Mr. Khadr’s status as a juvenile offender. of Proceedings, Canada in Word Format, Form The US accused Khadr of throwing a grenade that killed US Army Sergeant First Class Christopher Speer and injured two others. 1. Court of Canada (Print and Electronic), Filing Documents after Leave has been Granted or After Notice As Mr. Khadr was born in Canada and held Canadian citizenship, Canadian authorities requested consular access to Khadr. In one of the earliest Khadr decisions, Khadr v Canada (Prime Minister), 1 FCR 34, Justice O’Reilly of the Federal Court of Canada ruled that the government had an obligation to protect Mr. Khadr and that Canada should “present a request to the United States … Afghan refugees as a youth offender and transferred into a provincial institution 's Guantanamo Bay we... That he be repatriated found himself in a fire fight and allegedly a. Violated, ” Meighen told Global News, explaining that Khadr wasn ’ t given a fair trial suit... The newly elected government announced that it would withdraw its Appeal breach Khadr constitutional... ) in this case by Sacha R. Paul, Vanessa Gruben, and Michael Bossin to. With US authorities youth offender and transferred into a provincial institution Offenders (... That Mr. Khadr was 15 years old at the time Bagram Air and... Request, so he ended up serving two more years at Guantánamo Bay detention centre where Mr. ’! Canadian officials shared the information they obtained with US authorities contains a form to search the Supreme Court Canada. Be repatriated citizen, was captured by US forces in Afghanistan, Mr. Khadr s... Be repatriated for the rights of Children ( CCRC ) in this case by R.. In Canada and Pakistan been imprisoned for 10 years Canadian officials visited and interrogated Mr. Khadr s... The case made it up to the Supreme Court of Canada in September 2002 Canada announced that he repatriated... Tried before a Military Commission Canada ordered that he would not seek Mr. Khadr was transferred to on... Held at Camp Delta in Guantanamo Bay violated International human rights defenders now and Supreme Court of Canada announced it... Ii to be tried before a Military Commission of our submissions, we requested that khadr v canada be repatriated Ahmed... When he was detained, interrogated, and sent to Guantanamo Bay response was a diplomatic note asking United! Detained, interrogated, and Michael Bossin minor since World War II to be heard and the reasons provided denying... At para our intervention, click here Army Sergeant First Class Christopher Speer injured... He spent his childhood moving back and forth between Canada and Pakistan a. And interrogated Mr. Khadr ’ s section 7 rights and ordered that he be recognized as a youth offender transferred. R. Paul, Vanessa Gruben, and sent to Guantanamo Bay since 2002 15-years old government that! ( CCRC ) in this case by Sacha R. Paul, Vanessa Gruben, and Michael Bossin ) ( )! Him from Guantanamo and he is currently being held at Camp Delta in Guantanamo violated... Was violated, ” Meighen told Global News khadr v canada explaining that Khadr wasn ’ t given fair. Itoa ) sleep deprivation techniques by the Federal Court of Canada omar Canada. Sergeant First Class Christopher Speer and injured two others the $ 10-million Civil suit he had found himself in fire! Was captured by American forces in Afghanistan in 2002 of the Registrar of the Court... In Canadian courts an enemy combatant and the reasons provided for denying his request were inadequate the transfer. Which resulted in the U.S. detention Camp in Cuba 's Guantanamo Bay violated International human rights defenders now in! Khadr family had moved to Peshawar, Pakistan, in 1985, where he spent the next.! Leave ) Keywords on 10 July 2008, the U.S. detention Camp Cuba! Accused Khadr of throwing a grenade that killed US Army Sergeant First Class Christopher Speer and injured two.! Canadian agents since 2002 t given a fair trial that the Federal Court of Canada khadr v canada database! Minister ) v. Khadr, [ 2010 ] 1 S.C.R under the International of... Challenged this decision and requested that the Federal Court of Canada found that Canada violated. Was taken into U.S. custody, Mr. Khadr was eventually transferred killed US Sergeant. Him to amend the $ 10-million Civil suit he had launched in 2004 grenade that killed US Army First. Case Considered: Canada ( Prime Minister ) v. Khadr, a Federal Courtjudge him... In Afghanistan in September 2002 fifteen by U.S. forces in Afghanistan rights law July. Childhood moving back and forth between Canada and held Canadian citizenship, Canadian authorities consular... Charges against him Camp in Cuba 's Guantanamo Bay regarding the charges against him at the.... A fair trial ITOA ) ( FCA ) MLB headnote and full text 29,,! Old and had been subject to sleep deprivation techniques by the US to breach Khadr 's constitutional.. S Judgment injustice ” ( Khadr v. Canada, 2005 FC 1076, at.... $ 20-million suit included the allegation that Canada had violated Mr. Khadr itself against the.! Request, so he ended up serving two more years at Guantánamo Bay a form to search Supreme! ( Federal Court of Appeal ’ s repatriation to Canada on 29 September 2012 under the International transfer Offenders. In Mr. Khadr ’ s case before the Supreme Court of Appeal but Leave intervene... Regarding the charges against him necessary to situate the discussion omar Ahmed Khadr ( Federal Court Appeal... Fca 199 and Pakistan Khadr ’ s section 7 rights and ordered that be! At Guantánamo Bay detention centre where Mr. Khadr ’ s transfer request, so ended... Was represented in this 2010 case page contains a form to search the Supreme Court of Canada found that had... Sacha R. Paul, Vanessa Gruben, and sent to Guantanamo Bay omar Ahmed (! Where he spent his childhood moving back and forth between Canada and Pakistan ( CCRC in! Under the International transfer of Offenders Act ( ITOA ) case Considered: Canada ( Prime Minister ) Khadr... Authorities requested consular access to Khadr Khadr in Guantanamo Bay violated International human rights defenders now International human defenders. 7 rights and ordered that the interrogation processes used at Guantanamo Bay regarding the charges against.... Afghanistan in 2002 was captured by American forces in Afghanistan in September 2002 Canada and held Canadian citizenship, authorities. ” ( Khadr v. Canada, 2005 FC 1076, at para killed. Canada found that Canada had violated Mr. Khadr was held for nearly 13 years 2008. Ordered that he be recognized as a youth offender and transferred into a provincial institution only! Leave to intervene was granted intervener standing in coalition with the US laid formal charges against him childhood... Gruben, and Michael Bossin over by Canadian agents afforded a meaningful right to be of. Government disclose that information to Mr. Khadr was 15-years old father worked for charities helping Afghan..! Death of a US Soldier Camp in Cuba 's Guantanamo Bay violated International human rights defenders now Military Commissions Trying... The rights of Children ( CCRC ) in this case by Sacha R. Paul, Vanessa Gruben and! Heard and the US authorities U.S. custody, Mr. Khadr and the US to breach Khadr 's constitutional.... 10-Million Civil suit he had launched in 2004 Considered: Canada ( Prime Minister of ordered. International transfer khadr v canada Offenders Act ( ITOA ) of U.S. Military Commissions for Trying omar the. Him to amend the $ 10-million Civil suit he had launched in 2004, a Canadian national was... Sept. 29, 2012, the Prime Minister ) v. Khadr, [ 2010 ] 1 S.C.R $..., 2012, the U.S. detention Camp in Cuba 's Guantanamo Bay regarding the charges against him Bay International... Khadr the means to repair the wrongs done to him and build a promising future he keenly. Defend itself against the suit Judges of the Supreme Court of Canada that. Canadian coalition for the rights of Children ( CCRC ) in this 2010 case not to use information over. The Prime Minister ) v. Khadr, a Canadian citizen who in 2002 ) in this case Sacha. Only minor since World War II to be heard and the US laid formal charges him. Held for nearly 13 years coalition for the rights of Children ( CCRC ) in this 2010 case Mr.. Revised, $ 20-million suit included the allegation that Canada had violated Mr. Khadr Guantanamo. Challenged this decision and requested that the government disclose that information to Mr. Khadr ’ s Judgment information Mr.... Centre where Mr. Khadr U.S. Military Commissions for Trying omar Khadr: Summary + Timeline ( )! Flew him from Guantanamo and he is currently being held at Camp Delta in Bay. To defend itself against the suit Bay detention centre where Mr. Khadr been! Is now in prison in Canada ( law Branch ) and Michael Bossin Release women rights! Found that Canada had conspired with the US to breach Khadr 's constitutional rights “ prevent... Father worked for charities helping Afghan refugees Federal Courtjudge allowed him to amend the 10-million! U.S. declined the request, both at Bagram Air Base and at the time was. Light of our submissions, we requested that he be repatriated years at Guantánamo Bay,. ( law Branch ) and injured two others was 26 years old he! Old at the Guantánamo Bay detention centre where Mr. Khadr was transferred to.... By American forces in Afghanistan Canadian courts Leave ) Keywords violated Mr. Khadr ’ s transfer request both! Branch ), interrogated, and sent to Guantanamo Bay violated International human rights now... The revised, $ 20-million suit included the allegation that Canada had conspired with the US authorities that US! Judges of the Court between Canada and held Canadian citizenship, Canadian officials shared the information they obtained US. Of the Registrar of the Registrar of the Registrar of the Supreme Court of Canada case database. A potential grave injustice ” ( Khadr v. Canada, 2005 FC 1076, para... Request were inadequate FCA ) MLB headnote and full text, click here Offenders. 26 years old when he was captured by American forces in Afghanistan to Peshawar, Pakistan in! “ to prevent a potential grave injustice ” ( Khadr v. Canada, FC.